దోహా 17
यह सोपान ‘धर्म-राज्य’ से ‘धर्म-त्याग’ की ओर अंतर्मुख यात्रा है: समाज-उत्सव (राजतिलक) के बीच ईश्वर-लीला का उलटाव (वनगमन) दिखाकर तुलसी ‘अनुकूल-प्रतिकूल’ दोनों में राम-शरणागति का अभ्यास कराते हैं। यहाँ साधक के लिए मुख्य द्वार है—‘इच्छित सिद्धि’ के क्षण में भी वैराग्य, संयम, और भगवत्-प्रसाद-बुद्धि।
तुम्हहि न सोचु सोहाग बल निज बस जानहु राउ।मन मलीन मुह मीठ नृप राउर सरल सुभाउ।।17।।
tumhahi na socu sohāga bala nija basa jānahu rāu |mana malīna muha mīṭha nṛpa rāura sarala subhāu ||17||
మీకు చింత లేదు, భర్త ప్రేమ బలంపై నమ్మకం ఉంచి, రాజు మీ అధీనంలో ఉన్నాడని తలచుకుంటున్నారు. కాని రాజు మనసుతో కళంకితుడు, నోటి మాటతో మాత్రమే ఇంపుగలవాడు, మీ స్వభావం మాత్రం సరళమైనది, మోసరహితమైనది.
Speaker
Manthara
Listener
Kaikeyi
Karuna (with a Bhayanaka undertone), seen through the tragic misguidance that sets the Lord's exile in motion
In Ayodhya, on the eve of Rama's installation, Manthara works on Kaikeyi's mind. Having stirred her fear of a rival, she now tells her that she is wrongly secure in her husband's love and that the king's sweet words hide a different heart.
Ramrajya rests on satya and sincerity, where word and heart agree. This verse shows the opposite, a poisoning of trust between husband and wife by insinuation. It warns that a simple, guileless nature is easy prey for the flatterer and the schemer, and that a ruler's household needs honest counsel.
The verse is a worldly accusation, but it rests on the split between the hidden and the manifest: the inner mind (mana) against the spoken word (mukha). Tulsidas's wider vision is of the unseen Lord revealed in a visible form, and here that gap is turned into suspicion and deceit. Manthara's false reading of appearance is the human counterpart of true discernment.
Manthara tells Kaikeyi that she has no fear because she trusts in the power of her good fortune as a beloved wife and thinks the king is wholly in her hands. She then undercuts that confidence: the king, she says, is foul of mind and sweet only of tongue, while Kaikeyi's own nature is simple and guileless. The point is to make Kaikeyi doubt the sincerity of her husband's affection and see herself as an easy victim. Traditional commentators read it as a model of the slanderer's art, which flatters the victim's innocence in order to unsettle her trust. It is another step by which Manthara turns the queen's mind against the coronation.
Doha (13/11 matra pattern per line, 24 matras per line, rhyming at the line ends: राउ / सुभाउ)
Virodhabhasa or antithesis in 'मन मलीन' against 'मुह मीठ', which sets the inner against the outer. Anuprasa (alliteration) in the repeated m- sounds of 'मन मलीन मुह मीठ' and the s- sounds of 'सोचु सोहाग' and 'सरल सुभाउ'. Vyajokti or insinuation in the whole speech, where an apparent concern for Kaikeyi's welfare is meant to wound her trust in the king.
The verse speaks of worldly delusion: Kaikeyi trusts the outward show and takes the inner reality to be what Manthara paints. In Tulsidas's Vishishtadvaita-leaning view, this is the working of maya on a jiva who has lost discernment. The verse also shows how the mind (mana) can be made impure by bad counsel.
Raga Darbari Kanada or Bhairavi, for the grave, uneasy mood of a tragic turning point. Their low, weighty phrases suit a verse of insidious persuasion.
तुम्हहि | न | सोचु | सोहाग | बल | निज | बस | जानहु | राउ |
मन | मलीन | मुह | मीठ | नृप | राउर | सरल | सुभाउ ||
मंथरा कहती है कि कैकेयी निश्चिंत है क्योंकि वह अपने सोहाग के बल पर राजा को अपने वश में मानती है। फिर वह कहती है कि राजा मन के मैले और मुँह के मीठे हैं, जबकि कैकेयी का स्वभाव सरल है। इस प्रकार वह रानी के विश्वास को हिलाना चाहती है।
यहाँ मन के मैलेपन और मुँह की मिठास का विरोध दिखाया गया है, इसलिए विरोधाभास या विरोध का भाव है। साथ ही 'म' वर्ण की आवृत्ति से अनुप्रास भी बनता है। भाव यह है कि राजा की बातें मीठी हैं पर हृदय में कपट है, ऐसा मंथरा जताना चाहती है।
यह दोहा दिखाता है कि जहाँ वचन और हृदय में मेल नहीं होता, वहाँ विश्वास टूटता है। साथ ही यह चेताता है कि सरल स्वभाव का व्यक्ति चापलूस और कुमंत्री की बातों में आसानी से आ जाता है। रामराज्य में सत्य, सरलता और निष्कपट परामर्श को आदर्श माना गया है।
Answers come straight from the texts, with the shlokas they draw on. Ask in your own words.
A free sign-in with Google or Apple keeps your chat saved across web and the app.