दशरथस्य शोकानुचिन्तनं शब्धवेधि-दोषस्मरणं च
Daśaratha’s grief, karmic reflection, and the remembered ‘śabdavedhī’ misdeed
Addressed to DasharathaSetting: Forest near a water-source (implied by the episode of drawing water)Places named: vana
ऋषेर्हिन्यस्तदण्डस्य वने वन्येन जीवतः ।
कथं नु शस्रेण वधो मद्विधस्य विधीयते ॥३०॥
ṛṣer hi nyasta-daṇḍasya vane vanyena jīvataḥ |
kathaṃ nu śastreṇa vadho mad-vidhasya vidhīyate ||30||
Gdyż jestem ascetą, który odłożył przemoc na bok, żyjąc w lesiu z leśnym pożywieniem, jakże bowiem zabicie kogoś takiego jak ja może być dokonane bronią?
'Renouncing violence I live the life of an ascetic on forest produce. Why should any one kill me with a weapon?
Even unintended violence becomes grievous when born of heedlessness; restraint and right discernment are integral to dharma.
Cultivates vigilance (apramāda) and compassion; reflection on ahiṃsā in daily conduct.
The non-injuring renunciate (saṃnyāsin/śramaṇa ideal) harmed by ignorance (avidyā) underscores the peril of acting without right knowledge (yathārtha-jñāna).
Ahiṃsā and restraint as marks of the higher life (echoing later śānti/ahiṃsā ideals associated with Upaniṣadic discipline).
Mahābhārata, Āraṇyaka-parvan: ascetics harmed by kings’ errors (general parallel); Rāmacaritamānasa, Ayodhyākāṇḍa: Daśaratha’s lament over Śravaṇa episode (parallel narrative)
Vedic/Smṛti ahiṃsā and the sin of harming a muni
Vālmīki Rāmāyaṇa 2.63 (Śravaṇa’s speech to Daśaratha); Vālmīki Rāmāyaṇa 2.64 (Daśaratha’s remorse and meeting the parents)
Anuṣṭup
Grieving
Anudātta-prāya with soft udatta rises on interrogatives (kathaṃ nu)
Those who renounce violence deserve protection; dharma requires safeguarding the harmless, not endangering them through force or negligence.
The victim identifies himself as non-violent and questions the moral logic of being killed with a weapon.
Ahimsa (non-harming) and austerity—his life is portrayed as disciplined and innocent.
Answers come straight from the texts, with the shlokas they draw on. Ask in your own words.
A free sign-in with Google or Apple keeps your chat saved across web and the app.