Skanda Purana — Nagara Khanda, Shloka 5
श्रुतिस्मृतिविरुद्धं च कर्म सद्भिर्विगर्हितम् । जामदग्न्येन तच्चीर्णं कस्मात्सूत वदस्व नः
śrutismṛtiviruddhaṃ ca karma sadbhirvigarhitam | jāmadagnyena taccīrṇaṃ kasmātsūta vadasva naḥ
Hành vi ấy trái với Śruti và Smṛti, lại bị người hiền thiện quở trách. Vậy vì sao Jāmadagnya đã làm việc đó? Xin nói cho chúng tôi, hỡi Sūta.
Ṛṣis (the sages)
Type: kshetra
Listener: Sūta
Scene: A circle of brāhmaṇas/sages questioning the Sūta: one points to a manuscript labeled śruti-smṛti, another gestures in disapproval, demanding why Jāmadagnya performed a censured act.
FAQs
Dharma is measured against śāstra: even revered figures are examined through the lens of Śruti–Smṛti and the judgment of the righteous.
The inquiry continues within the Rāmahrada episode; the focus is on the reason behind the act rather than a new tīrtha.
No prescription; it raises a doctrinal problem—how a Śruti–Smṛti-contrary act could be attributed to Jāmadagnya.