अष्टसप्ततितमः सर्गः · Śatrughna’s Fury and Bharata’s Restraint
Mantharā Episode
Spoken by Śatrughna to BharataSetting: AyodhyaImmediately after exile decision; debate on preventing departure
बलवान्वीर्यसम्पन्नो लक्ष्मणो नाम योऽप्यसौ ।
किं न मोचयते रामं कृत्वा स्म पितृनिग्रहम् ॥३॥
balavān vīryasampanno lakṣmaṇo nāma yo 'py asau |
kiṁ na mocayate rāmaṁ kṛtvā sma pitṛnigraham ||3||
Dan mengapa Lakṣmaṇa, yang gagah perkasa dan penuh keberanian, tidak membebaskan Rāma dengan menahan ayahanda kita?
And why did not Lakshmana who is strong and powerful release Rama from exile by restraining our father?
Strength without discernment can become adharma; true valor may lie in restraint when higher dharma (obedience, social stability) is at stake.
Practice of channeling anger into disciplined service; remembering Rāma as the axis of dharma when emotions surge.
Tension between svadharma (one’s role-duty) and universal dharma; the mind’s impulse to ‘fix’ outcomes versus surrender to ordained order.
Īśā Upaniṣad’s spirit of tyāga is inverted here as the speaker urges forceful intervention rather than renunciation.
Vālmīki Rāmāyaṇa 2.18–2.21 (Lakṣmaṇa’s anger and readiness to oppose the exile); Vālmīki Rāmāyaṇa 2.21–2.22 (Rāma restraining Lakṣmaṇa, insisting on obedience)
Mahābhārata: debates on restraining elders for dharma (e.g., Bhīma’s impulses vs Yudhiṣṭhira’s restraint)
Ayodhyākāṇḍa scenes where Lakṣmaṇa proposes coercive measures to protect Rāma/Daśaratha
Anuṣṭup (śloka)
Commanding
Tāra-udātta (raised, sharp emphasis)
It probes the limits of righteous action: even justified outrage must consider dharma—whether ‘restraining the father’ is lawful or an unacceptable breach of filial and royal order.
Śatrughna questions why Lakṣmaṇa did not intervene forcefully to prevent Rāma’s exile, reflecting the family’s turmoil after Daśaratha’s decision.
Lakṣmaṇa’s self-control by implication: despite strength, he does not violate dharma by coercing the king, showing restraint over impulsive force.
Answers come straight from the texts, with the shlokas they draw on. Ask in your own words.
A free sign-in with Google or Apple keeps your chat saved across web and the app.