The Glory of Mathurā: The Account of Piṇḍa-Offering at the Catuḥsāmudrika Well
Pūrva Bhāga · Narrative Ethics (Householder Conduct; Neglect of Dharma)
धनयुक्तोऽपि पापोऽसौ न ददाति कदाचन ॥ नैवान्यमतिदातारं शक्नोति च निरीक्षितुम् ॥
dhanayukto 'pi pāpo 'sau na dadāti kadācana || naivānyam atidātāraṃ śaknoti ca nirīkṣitum ||
dhanayukto.api pApo.asau na dadAti kadAchana || naivAnyamatidAtAraM shaknoti cha nirIkShitum
उसके पास पैसा था, लेकिन वो बुरा आदमी कभी कुछ देता नहीं था। जो लोग बहुत दान करते थे, उन्हें देख भी नहीं सकता था।
Varāha (narrating)
Adharma matures from non-performance (not giving) into active hostility toward dharma embodied in others (hatred of the generous).
Counter envy by deliberate praise of virtue, small anonymous giving, and seeking satsanga with charitable people rather than avoiding them.
Wealth without dāna is ethically sterile; envy/aversion toward great donors is itself a sign of deeper pāpa and social-dharmic rupture.
Isolation from sādhus and puṇya-fields; intensified inner mala (envy, hatred) leading to further demerit and unfavorable rebirth trajectories per purāṇic moral causality.
Varāha Purāṇa 165.7 (no intention to give)
It intensifies the ethical portrait by adding social aversion to generosity, a narrative technique that depicts vice as both personal habit and social disposition.
No new geographic name is introduced in this verse.
Material capacity is not treated as an excuse; refusal to give despite wealth—and resentment toward generous people—is framed as a serious moral failing.
Answers come straight from the texts, with the shlokas they draw on. Ask in your own words.
A free sign-in with Google or Apple keeps your chat saved across web and the app.