Dīkṣā, Mantra-Types, Mantra-Doṣas, and Qualifications of Ācārya–Śiṣya
निर्बीजः सिद्विहीनश्च मंदः कूटो निरंशकः । सत्त्वहीनः केकरश्च बीजहीनश्च धूमितः ॥ १७ ॥
nirbījaḥ sidvihīnaśca maṃdaḥ kūṭo niraṃśakaḥ | sattvahīnaḥ kekaraśca bījahīnaśca dhūmitaḥ || 17 ||
Spesimen demikian tanpa benih, tanpa kesempurnaan yang semestinya, tumpul, bengkok, tanpa bagian yang layak; tanpa daya-sattva, berwujud cacat, kembali tanpa benih, dan berwarna kelam seperti asap.
Sanatkumara (teaching Narada in a technical/diagnostic listing within Book 1.3)
Vrata: none
Primary Rasa: shanta
Secondary Rasa: bibhatsa
It stresses discernment (viveka) in Dharma: what is offered, used, or relied upon should be fit, complete, and vital—defective or impure things obstruct auspicious results.
Bhakti values sincerity and purity; this list functions as a caution that blemished or unsuitable supports (materials, conduct, or mindset) weaken devotional practice and its fruit.
Lakṣaṇa-based technical evaluation—using precise Sanskrit descriptors to classify defects—supports ritual correctness and shastric decision-making in applied Vedic disciplines.