Shloka 9
सत्य–अनृत, प्रकाश–तमस्, स्वर्ग–नरक विवेचनम्
Truth and Untruth as Light and Darkness; Svarga and Naraka as Ethical Consequences
कीदृशो जीवतां जीव: कक््य वा गच्छन्ति ये मृता: । परलोकमिमं चापि सर्व शंसितुमरहसि,“जीवित प्राणियोंका जीवात्मा कैसा है? जो मर गये, वे कहाँ चले जाते हैं? तथा यह लोक और परलोक कैसा है? यह सब मुझे बतानेकी कृपा करें”
kīdṛśo jīvatāṃ jīvaḥ kva vā gacchanti ye mṛtāḥ | paralokam imaṃ cāpi sarvaṃ śaṃsitum arhasi ||
Bhīṣma asks for a clear account of the nature of the living self within beings: where those who die proceed after death, and what this world and the next are like. He urges the teacher to explain these matters fully, as essential to right understanding and right conduct.
भीष्म उवाच
Educational Q&A
The verse frames a foundational dharmic inquiry: understanding the nature of the jīva (individual self), the post-death trajectory of beings, and the relation between this world and the next. Such knowledge is presented as necessary for orienting ethical life—how one should act when actions have consequences beyond a single lifetime.
In the instruction-heavy setting of the Śānti Parva, Bhīṣma—speaking as an elder authority—poses a direct question to the interlocutor/teacher, requesting a comprehensive explanation about the self, death, and the structure of worldly and otherworldly existence.