Shloka 33
Śreyas-nirdeśa (Discerning the Superior Good): Nārada–Gālava Saṃvāda
अन्तवद्ध्विरुत प्राज्ञ: क्षत्रयज्जै: पिशाचवत् । मेरे-जैसा ज्ञानवान् पुरुष हिंसाप्रधान पशुयज्ञोंद्वारा कैसे यजन कर सकता है? अथवा पिशाचके समान विनाशशील क्षत्रिय--यज्ञोंके अनुष्ठानमें कैसे प्रवृत्त हो सकता है ।।
antavaddhviruta prājñaḥ kṣatrayajjaiḥ piśācavat | mere-jaisā jñānavān puruṣa hiṃsāpradhāna paśuyajñair dvārā kathaṃ yajanaṃ karotu? athavā piśācake samāna vināśaśīla kṣatriya-yajñānāṃ anuṣṭhāne kathaṃ pravṛttaḥ syāt ||
Wika ni Bhīṣma: “Paano makagagawa ang tunay na marunong—yaong nakakabatid sa wakas ng lahat ng may katawan—ng mga handog na pinaghaharian ng karahasan, gaya ng pag-aalay ng hayop? At paano naman ang isang kṣatriya, na ang buhay ay kasing-lupaypay ng isang ghoul, ay magpapasok ng sarili sa pagsasagawa ng gayong ‘mga handog ng kṣatriya’?”
भीष्म उवाच
Educational Q&A
Wisdom grounded in the awareness of impermanence should not endorse or pursue ritual action that is primarily violent; ethical discernment can override socially normalized forms of sacrifice.
In Bhishma’s instruction during the Shanti Parva, he questions the propriety of violent sacrificial rites—especially animal sacrifices and ‘kshatriya’ forms of ritual—arguing that a wise person, and even a perishable warrior, should hesitate to engage in such harm-based observances.