Chaupai 207.1-4
Tyāga-śikṣā (instruction in renunciation) and Dharma-parīkṣā (testing of righteousness): the sādhaka learns that true ‘Ayodhyā’ (the unconquerable inner city of peace) is entered not by possession of kingdom, but by surrender to Rāma’s maryādā. This sopāna turns grief into bhakti by transmuting political injustice into spiritual resolve—especially through Bharata’s spotless love and the community’s lament that becomes kīrtan-like praise.
यहउ कहत भल कहिहि न कोऊ।लोकु बेद बुध संमत दोऊ।।
तात तुम्हार बिमल जसु गाई।पाइहि लोकउ बेदु बड़ाई।।
लोक बेद संमत सबु कहई।जेहि पितु देइ राजु सो लहई।।
राउ सत्यब्रत तुम्हहि बोलाई।देत राजु सुखु धरमु बड़ाई।।
राम गवनु बन अनरथ मूला।जो सुनि सकल बिस्व भइ सूला।।
सो भावी बस रानि अयानी।करि कुचालि अंतहुँ पछितानी।।
तहँउँ तुम्हार अलप अपराधू।कहै सो अधम अयान असाधू।।
करतेहु राजु त तुम्हहि न दोषू।रामहि होत सुनत संतोषू।।
yahau kahata bhala kahihi na koū |loku beda budha saṁmata doū ||
tāta tumhāra bimala jasu gāī |pāihi lokau bedu baṛāī ||
loka beda saṁmata sabu kahaī |jehi pitu dei rāju so lahaī ||
rāu satyabrata tumhahi bolāī |deta rāju sukhu dharamu baṛāī ||
rāma gavanu bana anaratha mūlā |jo suni sakala bisva bhai sūlā ||
so bhāvī basa rāni ayānī |kari kucāli aṁtahũ pachitānī ||
tahãũ tumhāra alapa aparādhū |kahai so adhama ayāna asādhū ||
karatehu rāju ta tumhahi na doṣū |rāmahi hota sunata saṁtoṣū ||
Even if you say this, no one will call it well said; for both the custom of the world and the Veda, approved by the wise, stand against it. My son, your spotless fame will be sung, and both the world and the Veda will give you high praise. All say what the world and the Veda approve: that he receives the kingdom to whom his father gives it. The king, true to his vow, called you and was giving you the kingdom, with happiness, righteousness and honour. Rama's going to the forest is the root of all calamity, and at hearing it the whole world was pierced with grief. The foolish queen, in the grip of destiny, devised that wicked scheme, and in the end repented of it. Even in this, any fault of yours is slight; whoever says otherwise is base, ignorant and wicked. Had you ruled, no blame would have fallen on you, and Rama would have been glad to hear of it.
Speaker
Sage Vasishtha
Listener
Bharata
Shanta (with Karuna and a Vatsalya undertone in the address 'tata')
At Chitrakuta, Vasishtha consoles Bharata, who is tormented by guilt over his mother's deed. He tells him that he is not to blame, that taking the kingdom would have been proper by the standards of the world and the Veda, and that Kaikeyi's folly came from destiny.
Dharma is judged by both custom (lok) and scripture (Veda): the kingdom goes to the one the father gives it to, and a person is blamed only for his own fault, not for another's folly. Just counsel removes the false guilt of an innocent and rests on Rama's approval as the final test.
The verse names Rama as the person whose going to the forest grieves 'sakal bisva' (the whole world) and whose gladness at hearing is the final measure of right action. The Lord is thus the universal moral centre and also a personal Rama whose pleasure the devotee seeks. The abstract order of lok and Veda is anchored in the manifest Rama.
Vasishtha tells Bharata that to say he should be blamed would be called right by no one, since the world, the Veda and the wise all hold otherwise. By the accepted rule, the kingdom belongs to the one the father gives it to, and Dasharatha, true to his vow, had called Bharata and given him the kingdom with happiness, righteousness and honour. Rama's exile is the root of calamity and has pierced the whole world with grief, but it came from Kaikeyi's folly under the force of destiny, and she repented in the end. Any fault of Bharata's is slight, and whoever alleges more is base, ignorant and wicked. Had he ruled, he would have been blameless and Rama would have rejoiced to hear of it.
Chaupai (16 matras per line, four lines of two units each; here eight lines in all, each of 16 matras, with a rhymed ending in -ऊ, -ई, -ला, -ऊ)
Anuprasa (alliteration) in 'लोकु बेद बुध संमत' and 'सुनत संतोषू'. Punarukti or repetition in 'लोक बेद' (lines 1, 2, 3) to stress the double authority. Rupaka in 'अनरथ मूला' (calamity as having a root) and 'भइ सूला' (grief as a piercing spear). Hetu or karana-kathana in 'भावी बस रानि अयानी' (destiny named as the cause). Arthantaranyasa in 'जेहि पितु देइ राजु सो लहई' (a general rule supporting the case). Vyatireka-like contrast between Bharata's 'अलप अपराधू' and the 'अधम अयान असाधू' who would accuse him.
The verse rests on the view that destiny (bhavi) works within the moral order and that the sinless devotee is not stained by a deed done by others. This accords with Tulsidas's Vishishtadvaita-leaning Saguna outlook, in which Rama's will and the devotee's inner purity matter more than outward events. Bharata's purity (bimal jasu) is a quality of the soul, not an accident of circumstance.
Raga Bhairavi, for its grave, consoling and tender mood, which suits a sage's calm reassurance of a grieving devotee.
यहउ | कहत | भल | कहिहि | न | कोऊ | लोकु | बेद | बुध | संमत | दोऊ ||
तात | तुम्हार | बिमल | जसु | गाई | पाइहि | लोकउ | बेदु | बड़ाई ||
लोक | बेद | संमत | सबु | कहई | जेहि | पितु | देइ | राजु | सो | लहई ||
राउ | सत्य-ब्रत | तुम्हहि | बोलाई | देत | राजु | सुखु | धरमु | बड़ाई ||
राम | गवनु | बन | अनरथ | मूला | जो | सुनि | सकल | बिस्व | भइ | सूला ||
सो | भावी | बस | रानि | अयानी | करि | कुचालि | अंतहुँ | पछितानी ||
तहँउँ | तुम्हार | अलप | अपराधू | कहै | सो | अधम | अयान | असाधू ||
करतेहु | राजु | त | तुम्हहि | न | दोषू | रामहि | होत | सुनत | संतोषू ||
भरत अपनी माता की करतूत के कारण अपने को दोषी मानकर ग्लानि में डूबे हैं। वशिष्ठ समझाते हैं कि भरत का अपराध बहुत थोड़ा है, उनका यश निर्मल है, और लोक तथा वेद दोनों उनकी प्रशंसा करेंगे। इस प्रकार वे भरत की आत्मग्लानि दूर करते हैं।
यहाँ लोक और वेद दोनों का मान्य नियम बताया गया है कि पिता जिसे राज्य दे, वही उसे पाता है। राजा दशरथ सत्यव्रती थे और उन्होंने भरत को बुलाकर सुख, धर्म और सम्मान के साथ राज्य देना चाहा था। अतः भरत का राज्य लेना मर्यादा के विरुद्ध नहीं होता।
राम का वन जाना सारे अनर्थ की जड़ है, जिसे सुनकर पूरा संसार शोक से विद्ध हो गया। वशिष्ठ कहते हैं कि भोली रानी भावी (दैव) के वश में होकर कुचाल कर बैठी और अंत में पछताई। इसलिए दोष भरत का नहीं, भावी और रानी की अज्ञानता का है।
Answers come straight from the texts, with the shlokas they draw on. Ask in your own words.
A free sign-in with Google or Apple keeps your chat saved across web and the app.