Shloka 9
Vasiṣṭha–Karāla-Janaka Saṃvāda: Aśuddha-Sevana, Guṇa-Dr̥ṣṭi, and Sāṃkhya–Yoga Ekārthatā
Mahābhārata 12.293
(धर्मेण सहितं यत् तु भवेदल्पफलोदयम् । तत् कार्यमविशड्केन कर्मात्यन्तं सुखावहम् ।।
dharmeṇa sahitaṃ yat tu bhaved alpaphalodayam | tat kāryam aviśaṅkena karmātyantaṃ sukhāvaham || yo hṛtvā gosahasrāṇi nṛpo dadyād arakṣitāḥ | sa śabdamātraphalabhāgū rājā bhavati taskaraḥ ||
Parāśara said: Even if an action yields only a small immediate gain, if it is joined with dharma it should be done without hesitation, for in the end it brings the highest well-being. But a king who seizes thousands of cows from others, gives them away as “charity,” and yet fails to protect his subjects—such a man receives only the empty reputation of generosity and kingship; in truth he is a thief and a robber.
पराशर उवाच
Educational Q&A
Do dharma-aligned actions even when they seem to yield little immediate benefit, because their long-term result is true welfare. Also, charity is invalid if it is funded by theft and paired with neglect of a ruler’s primary duty—protection; such a ruler is a thief, not a benefactor.
In the Śānti Parva’s instruction on conduct and kingship, Parāśara contrasts genuine dharmic action with performative generosity. He condemns a king who confiscates others’ cattle to donate them while failing to safeguard the people, declaring that such ‘kingship’ and ‘charity’ are only in name.