Shloka 57
Bhīma–Duryodhana Gadāyuddha Saṃkalpa
Resolve for the Mace Duel
सर्वे भवन्तो धर्मज्ञा: सर्वे शूरास्तनुत्यज: । वास्तवमें क्षत्रियधर्म बड़ा ही क्रूर, किसीकी भी अपेक्षा न रखनेवाला तथा अत्यन्त निर्दय है; अन्यथा तुम सब लोग धर्मज्ञ, शूरवीर तथा युद्धमें शरीरका विसर्जन करनेको उद्यत रहनेवाले होकर भी उस असहाय-अवस्थामें अभिमन्युका वध कैसे कर सकते थे ।।
yudhiṣṭhira uvāca | sarve bhavanto dharmajñāḥ sarve śūrās tanutyajaḥ | vāstavameṃ kṣatriyadharmo baḍā hī krūraḥ, kisīkī bhī apekṣā na rakhanevālā tathā atyanta nirdaya hai; anyathā tum sab log dharmajña, śūravīra tathā yuddhameṃ śarīraka visargana karaneko udyata rahanevāle hokar bhī usa asahāya-avasthāmeṃ abhimanyukā vadha kaise kara sakate the || 563 || nyāyena yudhyatāṃ proktā śakralokagatiḥ parā
Yudhiṣṭhira said: “All of you are knowers of dharma; all of you are heroes, ready to give up your bodies in battle. Yet in truth the kṣatriya’s code is terribly cruel—owing nothing to anyone and pitiless in its demands. Otherwise, how could you—dharma-knowing and valorous as you are, ever prepared to lay down your lives—have slain Abhimanyu when he was in a helpless condition? For those who fight by justice, the highest destiny is said to be the world of Śakra (Indra).”
युधिछिर उवाच
Educational Q&A
Even within kṣatriya duty, righteous warfare (nyāya) is the ethical standard; violating fairness—such as killing a warrior in a helpless state—stands condemned, and only just fighting is praised as leading to the highest reward (Indra’s world).
Yudhiṣṭhira rebukes the opposing warriors for Abhimanyu’s death, arguing that if they truly were dharma-knowing heroes, they would not have killed him when he was vulnerable; he contrasts this with the ideal of fighting justly, which is said to earn heavenly attainment.